Free sample lesson ยท The Art of Thinking Clearly
A Novelist's Private List of Errors
Why did a novelist write a private list of thinking errors to protect his money?
Lesson 1 of the Wondering course The Art of Thinking Clearly
A Novelist Guards His Money
Picture a novelist with money from his books and one worry: he might lose it on careless bets.
So Rolf Dobelli started a private list of systematic thinking errors to avoid frivolous gambles with his literary earnings.[[3]](https://fs.blog/the-art-of-thinking-clearly/)
The list was, in his words, "originally designed to be used by me alone."[[3]](https://fs.blog/the-art-of-thinking-clearly/)
It grew into The Art of Thinking Clearly, which the HarperCollins edition presents as 99 short chapters on common errors of judgment and how to avoid them.[[1]](https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Art_of_Thinking_Clearly.html?id=Zx2IMWJmJ_sC)

A private list of errors that became a book
Why would a written list help at all? Because the errors on it are not random.
Slip or Systematic Error?
Here is a made-up contrast. An analyst mistypes one figure in a report, once. Nobody else makes that mistake.
That is a slip: random, one-off, and impossible to predict.
Now a budget meeting. Someone says "about $2 million" first, and every estimate that follows lands near that number.
That is a systematic error. It leans the same way across many people, so you can predict it and write it down.
- One-off slip
- Systematic error
Only the second kind can go on a list in advance.
Why Smart People Fall For Them
If these errors are so predictable, why does anyone still make them?
Psychologists Tversky and Kahneman described mental shortcuts, or heuristics, that "are quite useful, but sometimes they lead to severe and systematic errors."[[6]](https://fbaum.unc.edu/teaching/articles/Science_1973_JudgmentUnderUncertainty.pdf)
- Mental shortcut: A heuristic for fast judgment.
- Usually works: Highly economical and usually effective.
- Sometimes errs: Severe and systematic errors.
- Same direction: Many people lean the same way.
- Predictable: So it can be written on a list.
The same shortcuts are "highly economical and usually effective." The errors come attached to tools that mostly serve us well. Because the shortcut usually works, its errors can feel natural: from the inside, a mistake feels just like a sound judgment. Being smart does not switch that feeling off.
Dobelli did not discover these errors. He calls himself "a translator" of other researchers' work.[[4]](https://www.dobelli.com/en/books/)
So how do you fight an error that comes from a tool that usually works?
Less Irrationality, Not More Tools
What did Dobelli prescribe? No new system. "All we need is less irrationality."[[3]](https://fs.blog/the-art-of-thinking-clearly/)
His UK publisher says you need no gadgets, complicated ideas, or frantic activity, only better choices.[[2]](https://www.hodder.co.uk/titles/rolf-dobelli/the-art-of-thinking-clearly/9781444759556/)
The book's epilogue gives this approach a name. Via negativa means the path of exclusion: instead of adding something new, you improve by shedding what is unnecessary or what obscures (clouds) your thinking.[[5]](https://www.publishersweekly.com/9780062219688)
- Not needed
- Gadgets
- Complicated ideas
- Frantic activity
- Needed
- Less irrationality
- Better choices: Reached by shedding what obscures.
So clear thinking starts with deletion. Find one known way you go wrong and remove it before reaching for anything fancy.
Add a Tool or Remove an Error?
Here is a made-up case. Two investors both had a year of poor results.
The first adds: a stock-screening app and new data to check.
The second removes one known error. Before each purchase, they write down why they would sell, in the spirit of Dobelli's list.
The second fix targets a known way of going wrong. The first adds more to look at, while the error stays in place.
Removing errors has a limit, though: it does not replace domain knowledge (understanding of the field you are deciding in) or good information. The chart below shows how to choose. Start from poor results and ask one question: is a known thinking error, one that could be on a list like Dobelli's, behind them? If yes, remove that error, as the second investor did. If no, look elsewhere: the cause may be a gap in what you know, so get better knowledge or information, or it may simply be bad luck. Either way, you then make your next decision with that fix in place.
- Poor results
- Is a known error behind it?
- Remove that error: Example: before buying, write down why you would sell.
- Get better knowledge or information: When no known error explains the results.
- Make the next decision
What the List Cannot Do
A list of errors is mostly a list of things to avoid.
Publishers Weekly notes the book gives little advice on what to pay attention to.[[5]](https://www.publishersweekly.com/9780062219688)
Its real use is preparation. Before a decision, name the error you are likely to make and decide in advance what you will do instead.
One question remains. If these errors are predictable, does simply knowing them protect you?
Check yourself
After poor investment results caused by a known thinking error, the stronger first fix is to _____.
- remove a known error
- add a new tool
Answer: remove a known error
The lesson recommends less irrationality: remove a known error before adding tools or more activity. A new app may add information while leaving the error in place.
A heuristic is a mental _____. Because it usually works, its errors can feel _____.
Answer: A heuristic is a mental shortcut. Because it usually works, its errors can feel natural.
Mental shortcuts are useful much of the time, so people may trust them even when they create severe, predictable errors.
Which situation shows a systematic thinking error rather than a one-off mistake?
- One analyst mistypes a figure once, and nobody repeats it.
- Several estimators give numbers close to the first number mentioned.
- One worker forgets a meeting after an unusually busy morning.
- A writer makes one spelling mistake in a draft.
Answer: Several estimators give numbers close to the first number mentioned.
The budget estimates all move toward the first number in the same predictable direction. A single mistyped figure is a random slip, not a shared pattern.
Keep going
This is lesson 1 of 13 in The Art of Thinking Clearly. Next up:
- Why Knowing a Bias Isn't Enough
- Survivors and Swimmers' Bodies
- Patterns in Noise and Perfect Records
- Who Gets Credit for a Rebound?
- Hunting for Evidence Against Yourself
Wondering turns any topic into short lessons you can read, watch, or listen to, with practice questions and an AI tutor.